Thursday, January 18, 2007

Are CXR in preemployment check up justified?

The legal and medical basis for chest radiographs as part of pre-employment examinations (PEE) at a University Hospital is evaluated. The radiographs are primarily performed to exclude infectious lung disease. A total of 1760 consecutive chest radiographs performed as a routine part of PEEs were reviewed retrospectively. Pathologic findings were categorized as "nonrelevant" or "relevant." No positive finding with respect to tuberculosis or any other infectious disease was found; 94.8% of the chest radiographs were completely normal. Only five findings were regarded as "relevant" for the individual. No employment-relevant diagnosis occurred. The performance of chest radiography as part of a PEE is most often not justified. The practice is expensive, can violate national and European law, and lacks medical justification.
Are chest radiographs justified in pre-employment examinations? Presentation of legal position and medical evidence based on 1760 cases.
Radiologe 2006 Jul;46(7):567-73

Bookmark and Share
posted by Sumer Sethi @ Thursday, January 18, 2007   2 comments links to this post

2 Comments:

At 3:38 PM, Blogger Dr Abha Shroff said...

Dear Mr Sethi
I was pleasantly surprised to note this comment on your blog site. Something that I have been trying to tell companies and HR heads for quite some time now.
A chest x-ray should definitely not be a first line investigation for pre employment medical checkups.
Dr Abha Shroff

 
At 3:40 PM, Blogger Dr Abha Shroff said...

I agree with the contents of the article posted by you
Dr Abha Shroff
www.pathologylabindia.com

 

Post a Comment

Links to this post:

Create a Link

<< Home






 

 

Best Clinical Weblog

Site Feed

Photobucket - Video and Image Hosting

RADIOLOGY GRAND ROUNDS

INFORMATION FOR THE PATIENTS

Teleradiology Providers

RADIOLOGY JOBS

Newspaper review of this site

Sumer's Blog in Radiographics

Sumer's Blog on International Society of Radiology

View Sumer Sethi's profile on LinkedIn

ALL ABOUT SUMER SETHI

SUMER'S CURRICULUM VITAE

Fill out your e-mail address (Privacy: Your email address will be used by Sumer's Radiology Site only. We hate spam too)
To receive

DR SUMER'S RADIOLOGY NEWSLETTER!!!

Medical Weblogs

Blog Carnival archive - grand rounds

Radiology Book Store

Image hosted by Photobucket.com

We subscribe to the HONcode principles. Verify here.

Locations of visitors to this page

RSS to JavaScript

Blog Directory

 
VISIT MY MESSAGE BOARD
MY BOOKS AVAILABLE ONLINE
MY BOOK'S REVIEWS
TOP LINKS
IMAGES
CONFERENCES
ONLINE QUIZ
MNEMONICS
TUTORIALS
HISTORY OF RADIOLOGY
MAIL ME

follow me on Twitter





 
Web sumerdoc.blogspot.com

Searching Radiology


Visit Teleradiology Network

RSS to JavaScript

RSS to JavaScript

RSS to JavaScript

Blog Of The Day Awards Winner